Canon PRO-1000 vs CT-21

I have had a Canon PRO-1000 for some time, it is an amazing printer. It is a must for someone producing professional photographic image prints. I cannot stress how good quality it is.

But I have just replaced with a Canon CT-21. So I felt it's worth explaining why, and what difference it makes.

Do I need a photo printer?

The first point is whether I need a photo printer. It is my only colour printer, and I do print photos for the family that get framed and go on walls, and so on. But I print stuff like a menu with a colour logo on it, etc, which seems overkill to use a PRO-1000.

Basically, I probably do not need a professional photo printer, really. It is just my usual overkill.

What is my use now?

Given the ability to print up to A2, I have actually been using it for posters for the pub. They are stunning.

Is A2 big enough?

The catch is, posters at a pub, may want more, like A1. So I decided to get the TC-21, which is an A1 poster printer that takes roll paper feed. If someone accidentally orders A0 clip frames at the pub, I may be in trouble.

What of TM-255?

I considered the TM-255 - it uses 5 inks, not 4, but has a base, and is just so big. It looks great, but I simply did not have space. The TC-21 fits on my bench. The ™-255 is also high volume and stupidly quick, but the TC-21 is not a problem for what I need in terms of print speed.

Key points in favour of the PRO-1000

• The photo print quality is just amazing, cannot be faulted.
• It does edge to edge printing on most paper sizes (oddly not A5), which is very cool. Even A2.

Key points in favour of TC-21

• It does A1+. Indeed, it will do 610mm wide and 18m long if you want!!!
• It does roll paper feed (which I am using for A1+ or A2+), but it can take narrower paper roll.
• It does sheet feed (no need to take out rolls feed, just manual sheet feed via top loader), all the way down to A6. Very handy.
• Easy colour refill - the PRO-1000 is easy, but this is only 4 inks.

Some downsides for PRO-1000

• It uses 12 inks, this is a feature in terms of quality but a pain in terms of costs and hassle with ink. It also gets through "maintenance kits" which also cost.
• If you do not use for a while, weeks, it will waste a lot of ink and take ages to start up. But it will then print perfectly. I don't know if the TC-21 does this.

Some downsides of the TC-21

• It is bigger, check dimensions, but wider by quite a bit. Well, obviously it has to be.
• It does not do edge to edge well - it can get very close on roll feed, maybe 1mm each side, and cut with no margin top/bottom. But not at all on sheet feed. This is perhaps its main lack of feature.
• It is only CMYK not 12 inks, but the photo printing is still good, and good enough by far for some family photos.

I do not know running costs yet, but the results are pretty good.

New printer (Canon PRO-1000)

I have had, and used, many printers over time (for paper, not 3D).

Just off the top of my head :-

• Simple line of pins impact dot matrix through ribbon - classic. I had a few of these.
• Single "pin" with rotating roller behind paper to do dot matrix through ribbon - slow - prints one dot at a time moving up through the character, then the blade shaped head moves right to do next pixel one dot at a time.
• Band printers - I did not own one, but used one - has all the letters on a band, and it is fascinating watching the line form as each letter is printed when it is over the right space, printing many in the line at a time, so the line of text sort of forms in seemingly random order in front of your eyes.
• Daisy wheel, impact print through ribbon, but fun doing some graphics with a lot of full stops.
• A spark based printer, single wire high drags at high speed across the paper for each row burning off a silvered surface of the paper, dot matrix - creates a black on silver text.
• A spark jet printer, with a carbon rod in a glass tube making a spark to the paper and carrying carbon deposited on the page. Single glass tube moves at high speed back and forth over the paper. Like printing with pencil. I did my degree dissertation on that.
• A variety of thermal printers on thermal paper - head the width of paper. Fades rather easily.
• A variety of thermal transfer printers, transfer from film to normal paper, head the width of paper.
• A variety of thermal transfer multi-colour ribbon printers for photo printing.
• The plastic card printer we use at work, thermal transfer. Ive used two kinds of such printers.
• Normal A4 laser printers, postscript
• A3 laser printer, colour
• Ink jet printer
• Bubble jet printer
• Oh, and pen plotters

Wow, I have had a lot of printers. I suspect I have missed some out even.

Actually, I left out that I have used manual, movable lead type printing machines and done typesetting using actual fonts of lead type characters. Genuine upper and lower "cases". That was a long time ago. I must be old.

The printer I have used for a long time is a wax based printer - originally Tektronix, but now bought by Xerox. I like them as they are not as messy as using toner and do solid colours really well. You just drop in these wax blocks to load the ink, neat and tidy. They are OK (ish) for photo print, but for colour letterheads (which is why we got them originally) they are really nice. I even print red wax seals to use with an embossing seal, and well, it was actually wax.

The office moved on to other laser printers some time ago, and my printer here finally started playing up (sheet feeder issues), so I have decided it is time for a new printer, and I thought it would be nice to get an ink jet type printer, but why not get one that can do photos...

What I eventually got was a Canon PRO-1000. It can have a stack of A4 plain paper for the normal use cases, but can also take a variety of sizes up to A2, and do impressive high resolution professional quality photo prints, edge to edge, on photo paper. It does pretty good photos even on plain paper.

So, yes, it will be used for simple A4 prints most of the time. These days I print quite low volumes, and can alway use printers at work for printing something with a lot of pages. It also has separately replaceable ink cartridges, which I prefer. However, there have been occasions where we do want to print bigger than A4, mainly for circuit drawings, etc.

But yes, I can print really nice photographs now. This is printing an A2 map on plain paper.

I did consider getting the wider models, they can do roll based prints up to A0, or even bigger. You can print proper posters for adverts and the like. But no way it would fit in the man-cave sensibly. I was also not sure if it would do the simple A4 plain paper as easily. The PRO-1000 seems a good compromise. The print quality really is rather impressive and having the option of large prints is nice.