Police misleading the public to pass the Investigatory Powers Bill?

This is an excellent article that is well worth reading. http://www.thinksip.uk/2015/12/police-misleading-the-public-to-pass-the-communications-data-bill/

When I saw the tweet by NCA, I too thought it was misleading, but clearly the author of that article, Aled Treherne, has thought about it a lot more and has some experience in this area. He makes a lot of sense.

This is basically the same crap story that was trotted out when we met with the home office, and I find it shocking that it is still being pushed as if it made sense.

They also have a slightly different info-graphic (the one in blue) which is very nearly the same and full of exactly the same holes.

Finding which on-line services have been accessed is somewhat pointless - for a start, if an Apple phone, then it will be Apple, and almost certainly FaceBook, Twitter, and WhatsApp. There are only a few major on-line services that a kid might be accessing, and asking the parents and friends will get a lot more information a lot more quickly that waiting to convince a judge to order a foreign social media or messaging service to hand over information and hoping they comply.

They talk of linking actions to devices? Well, what action? having a FaceBook account? Basically, any social media or messaging service will have permanent connections and regular traffic regardless of "usage" or "actions", so Internet Connection Records tell you very little - you can probably link half the smart phones in they country to FaceBook - this helps you how exactly?

The very nature of social media is that people share things with their friends, so ask their friends what is going on - there may not even be an actual crime!

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated purely to filter out obvious spam, but it means they may not show immediately.

A sign of the times

There is an old road sign on Belmont Road, Abergavenny. Old, and rusty, and not even that easy to read. It was worse, it was covered in ivy,...